17 Ways Lean Manufacturing Benefits Concrete Manufacturers
Introduction
Why We Love Lean
This report provides a top-line review of lean manufacturing practices and the benefit they can provide to the infrastructure manufacturing industry. It is written for concrete manufacturers but is applicable to any party in the infrastructure supply chain.
Idencia is a technology service but we firmly believe that technology itself is not the means for improved productivity. Technology enables new work flows. New work flows are the real source of productivity gains.
Lean manufacturing practices, introduced in the 1950s by Toyota for automobile manufacturing, have since been applied in virtually every industry as work flow practices that improve productivity and increase customer satisfaction. New information technologies, particularly those that make possible the efficient collection and management of large amounts of data, create new possibilities for the application of lean manufacturing practices.
Technology enables new work flows, the real source of productivity gains.
The fundamental premise of lean manufacturing is that all activities should be concentrated in the value stream, defined as only those activities for which the customer would be willing to pay (more on this later). At Idencia, we believe that the customer value stream starts before the customer relationship, at our first touch with an industry member.
So, we offer this report to begin our value stream for the concrete manufacturing industry. We welcome the opportunity to pursue your lean journey with you.
The power of workflow
Technology and workflow
In some cases technology enables a complete transformation of work flow that revolutionizes an industry… or industries. Ford’s development of the assembly line transformed manufacturing in virtually every industry for most of the 20th century.
However, technology’s impact on work flow is usually much more incremental. A good example of this is the change that word processing created in the work of a secretary.
Before the introduction of the personal computer in the early 1980s, most of the work a secretary performed was taking dictation, typing and then re-typing the edits that the boss made after reading the first draft. The introduction of the PC produced two changes that profoundly improved productivity in the office:
It allowed the boss to type his or her own document and make changes along the way. This substantially shortened the cycle time required to produce a typed document; and
It revamped… and substantially upgraded… the job of a secretary by eliminating much of the (boring) typing, replacing it with more stimulating work in assisting the boss with other matters. Today, the person formerly titled “Secretary” is called “Administrative Assistant” because the value provided is much greater than note-taking and typing.
The same scenario plays out in any situation where technology is introduced to automate the mundane. This certainly applies to the infrastructure supply chain:
The Quality Control Manager using information technology to capture QC records (instead of a clipboard) is no longer required to spend time preparing reports because they are automatically generated. This allows much more time to be applied to improving quality.
The project owner that uses internet-of-things (IoT) technology to monitor the health of infrastructure changes the nature of an inspector’s work. The inspector now makes fewer inspections and applies time to investigating the most significant issues. The inspector can also recommend predictive maintenance based on analysis of the sensor data generated. In both cases, a much higher value use of an inspector’s time.
Most of what follows will produce incremental work flow improvements rather than revolutionary changes. But, don’t underestimate the exponential potential that can be realized by compounding incremental improvements throughout your manufacturing process.
The Ford story
The classic example of the power of work flow is Henry Ford’s introduction of the assembly line process for manufacturing automobiles. When the new technology of the early 1900s… electricity… was introduced it enabled manufacturing to occur anywhere in the plant instead of at fixed locations where generators were placed. With this, Ford was able to introduce the assembly line process, lowering the cost of manufacturing and enabling scale.
By reducing the cost of manufacturing, Ford was able to lower his prices… without impacting margins… to a level that was affordable for the middle class. Prior to this, car ownership was a luxury only for the wealthy. By using the new technology of the day to create the assembly line, Ford was able to: lower the cost of manufacturing, preserve margins, open a new market of middle class buyers and increase his production capacity, allowing him to serve his new market.
In the process, Ford applied one other very unconventional practice. He increased the wages he paid his people on the manufacturing line so that they could afford the cars he was making! As a result, the Ford Motor Company quickly became the dominant market leader in automobile manufacturing.
The lessons learned from Henry Ford’s success apply today and, in fact, present more opportunities now than they did for him. Simply stated:
Constantly improve work flow for productivity and customer satisfaction
Look for technology solutions that enable work flow innovation
Think contrarian
Lean manufacturing defined
Lean manufacturing is a practice, not a system. It is often defined as the practice of continually improving work flow to reduce waste and focus activities on those that produce customer value. It is a mindset first and foremost.
Let’s get started with some definitions:
Value Stream: The series of activities engaged by a vendor to create value for the customer.
Value Stream Mapping: Process of identifying (aka mapping) each step performed in the value stream. The process starts by defining the value the customer wants. (Quite often, this is not sufficiently understood by the vendor; more later.)
Flow: The sequential process of the value stream.
Constraints: Impediments to flow.
Waste: Any action or resource commitment that does not directly contribute to the value stream. (You will see that many actions considered necessary are actually waste because they do not contribute value to the customer.)
Pull: Demand from a customer that initiates the value stream process.
Lean manufacturing is a practice, not a system. It is a mindset first and foremost.
A lean practice requires that everything… everything… is considered from the customer’s perspective. By “the customer” we don’t mean the next party up the supply chain. We mean the party that is ultimately paying for the project. From this perspective, answers to the following questions need to be included in considering the delivery of value:
How do we deliver value demanded by the customer?
How do we deliver the product in sync with the customer’s flow?
How do we deliver services that the customer wants… or might want?
How do we continuously exceed the customers quality standards?
How do we deliver the product at the lowest possible cost?
Note that the answers to these questions are dynamic, not static. That is because these all describe the value stream, which is in a constant state of flow. They also make clear that the value stream should always be triggered and influenced by customer pull. Finally, all of this should be designed to happen with minimal waste.
Lean manufacturing is a practice, not a system, because it involves continual revision and rework as a matter of course. There is no end because there can always be more value added, more waste removed.
This is accomplished by routinely engaging in value stream mapping to determine:
What value your customers demand
What additional value can be offered
Where waste can be eliminated
Where constraints exist in your value stream
How constraints can be minimized or eliminated
One of the great things about a lean practice is that much of the above can be addressed through innovation, not necessarily additional investment. This is why companies that practice lean manufacturing are generally the most innovative, and therefore market leaders.
At Idencia, we hold lean planning sessions with the entire staff every Friday to review value stream mapping. A different person presents each week. By involving everyone, we find that:
Everyone sees the big picture, crucial to coordinated company direction;
Everyone remains focused on the value stream and actively participates;
Everyone sees the perspective of others and their contributions to the value stream;
Constraints and waste are more easily identified with ‘fresh eyes’ of others who are not involved in a particular activity on a day-to-day basis.
We are a small company so a weekly meeting of the entire staff is more practical than for a large company. In larger companies, the routine practice should be applied in smaller groups whose leaders then meet in similar fashion with each other.
There are many good resources that address lean manufacturing practices in more detail and provide excellent examples. Here are some of the best to get you started:
Websites
Lean Enterprise Institute
A 501(c)(3) nonprofit with a mission to make things better through lean thinking and practice. Founded in 1997 by management expert James P. Womack, PhD, LEI conducts research, teaches educational workshops, publishes books and ebooks, runs conferences, and shares practical information about lean thinking and practice. James Womack started the lean manufacturing movement in his work studying the Toyota Production System and advising US companies in the practices. He coined the term “lean manufacturing’.
Planet Lean
The official online magazine of the Lean Global Network, a consortium of not-for-profit organizations dedicated to advancing lean thinking and practice throughout the world. The Lean Global Network was also founded by James Womack.
Lean Six Sigma
WRITE SOMETHING HERE IT’S NEW
Books
Lean Thinking
A primer on lean practices written by James Womack and Daniel Jones. This is a seminal book that is easy to read. Definitely the first book you want to purchase.
Lean Production Simplified
A hands-on guide to implementing lean practices by Dennis Pascal, a former manager at Toyota who applies his learning of the Toyota Production System.
The Goal
By Dr. Eliyahu M. Goldratt in which his Theory of Constraints is illustrated in the form of a novel. This book shows clearly how to most effectively minimize work-in-process and demonstrates how WIP is the greatest single source of waste.
Value stream mapping
How do we create value?
There are two primary phases in value stream mapping
Determine the value that the customer wants
Chart the steps involved in providing the customer value
Let’s look at a value stream map that is typical for many precast manufacturers:
Addressing the first phase, determining the value a customer wants, is not as simple as the last step listed, “Deliver to Customer”. Yes, the customer wants delivery of the product but what else provides exactly the value the customer wants?
Delivery at a specific time?
Delivery of the product configured to plug into the construction sequence?
Delivery with QA documentation in electronic form?
Prior to delivery, real-time updates on production status?
Prior to delivery, the ability to change product spec or configuration?
These are phrased as questions because the only answers come from a discussion with the customer about what is wanted. As previously mentioned, this requires understanding with all parties in the supply chain, not just the contractor to whom the product is delivered.
Determining the value demanded by the customer is the most important element of lean practices. And, this is not a one-time process; it is an evolution. As your company engages in this practice you will see commonalities and trends occurring in the responses you receive. These can be incorporated into your value stream as standard practices. As you continue this practice the value of your products will become greater and your company will be recognized as an innovative leader.
How does this practice of determining real customer value contribute to the 17 ways precast manufacturers can increase profits and win bids?
Additional features/services enable higher pricing.
Customer collaboration will reveal new product opportunities.
Solving customers’ problems creates lasting affinity.
Your company will become branded as innovative.
Your company will quickly be recognized as an industry expert.
Your company will become branded as “easy to work with”.
Once you have identified the real value demanded by the customer, you need to work backwards and map your value stream as we did in Figure 1, above. This allows you to:
See every step in the value creation process
Identify areas where additional value might be created
Identify how we can most effectively operate in response to customer pull
Identify waste in the process
Identify constraints in the process that can be subsequently addressed
This is also where we can identify how technology might be applied to enhance the customer experience. For instance:
In the early part of the value stream, can we:
Offer customers electronic order entry?
Provide customers with an electronic interface to check production status?
Provide customers with an electronic interface for change orders?
And later in the value stream, does the customer want electronic access to the QA reports that are produced by the postpour inspection process?
How does mapping the value stream contribute to the 17 ways precast manufacturers can increase profits and win bids?
You can make your customer more efficient.
You can identify services that complement the product offering.
You can enable your customer experience to be seamless.
As we will discuss next, mapping the value stream also highlights efficiency that we can produce by identifying waste and reducing constraints.
Waste
Drag and opportunity
Waste is simultaneously the largest drag on most companies and the biggest opportunity for quick returns from implementing lean practices. There are two basic elements of waste:
Repetitive or unnecessary use of resources
Necessary use of resources that do not contribute to customer value
The waste highlighted in Figure 4 illustrates samples that have been identified to us in our work with the precast industry; clearly this is just the beginning. Waste can be addressed in three primary ways:
Understand cause
Take time to understand the root cause and modify:
Why are repairs required?
What forms are most often producing the products needing repair?
What can be done to repair the forms to reduce product repairs?
Who is most often causing repair issues?
Apply technology
Automate the mundane causes of waste, especially Necessary Waste, with technology:
Eliminate time spent on preparing reports
Eliminate time spent on the phone responding to inquiries
Reduce time spent searching for inventory in the yard
Reduce shipping mistakes
Minimize inventory
Inventory is the single largest source of waste. We have had customers tell us that they have held pieces in the yard for 2 years or more. Every day that piece sits, cash is tied up that could otherwise be put to productive use.
The most effective way to reduce inventory is to build only in response to customer pull.
Producing in response to customer pull requires the shortest possible cycle time. We reduce cycle time by removing constraints as we’ll discuss next.
How does the practice of identifying waste in the value stream contribute to the 17 ways precast manufacturers can increase profits and win bids?
Wasteful costs are identified and removed.
Repetitive actions are eliminated.
Costs of necessary waste are reduced by automation.
Inventory needs will be minimized going forward.
Constraints
Bottlenecks of waste
Constraints are factors in the value stream that limit the ability to accomplish a process or increase the time required to complete it. They are therefore a variant of waste that, when removed, can shorten the production cycle time, eliminate waste and enable the greatest possible operating efficiency.
Since processes in the value stream are interdependent, every process can be constrained by factors unique to it and factors related to other processes:
Lean practices involve the continual review of:
Process cycle time
Process constraints
Solutions for reducing or removing constraints
The Goal, an easy-to-read novel by Eliyahu Goldratt referenced above, provides an excellent, in-depth description of Goldratt's Theory of Constraints and provides effective, counter-intuitive methods for addressing them to improve cycle time.
How does the practice of identifying and eliminating constraints in the value stream contribute to the 17 ways precast manufacturers can increase profits and win bids?
Shortening the production cycle time will reduce costs.
Shortening the production cycle time will increase capacity.
Shortening the cycle will enable better customer response.
Eliminating constraints will generate cash by reducing inventory.
Conclusion
Discipline and opportunity
It is obvious by now that a continuous practice of lean methods is scientific in nature; a process of inquiry, hypothesis, trial, and review. As such, it requires practitioners to establish baseline measurements, set performance benchmarks, measure results and repeat.
Here, again, is where the application of information technology can be a catalyst for improvement. Using mobile technology to collect data from the plant and web-hosted data storage to access and manage data creates efficiency in the management of lean practices and eliminate the constraints of:
Inaccuracy from transferring hand-written data
Time spent collecting data
Time spent producing reports
Time spent analyzing data
Time spent searching for information
At Idencia, we believe that the adoption of lean practices throughout the infrastructure supply chain will be essential to the industry meeting the unprecedented need for (up to) $4.6 trillion of infrastructure investment by 2025 (as estimated by the American Society of Civil Engineers).
In the meantime, early practitioners can immediately benefit from the:
17 ways lean manufacturing increases profits and win bids
Identify Customer Value
1. Additional features/services enable higher pricing
2. Customer collaboration will reveal new product opportunities
3. Solving customers’ problems creates lasting affinity
4. Become branded as innovative
5. Be recognized as an industry expert
6. Become branded as “easy to work with”
Reduce Waste
10. Wasteful costs are identified and removed
11. Repetitive actions are eliminated
12. Costs of necessary waste are reduced by automation
13. Inventory needs will be minimized going forward
Map the Value Stream
7. Make your customer more efficient
8. Identify services that complement the product offering
9. Enable your customer experience to be seamless
Eliminate Constraints
14. Shortening the production cycle time will reduce costs
15. Shortening the production cycle time will increase capacity
16. Shortening the cycle will enable better customer response
17. Eliminating constraints will generate cash by reducing inventory
Idencia in a nutshell
Idencia is a plant management solution that provides tools for plant managers to streamline and optimize their operations. As a company, Idencia strives to benefit the precast concrete industry as a whole.
Contact us
sales@idencia.com
(603) 541-7704